American Idol -- 8th Season

Cincy Fan 44 wrote:Gotta say I'm somewhat surprised Kris won. I still think Adam is better though. Time will tell which one has a better career...

Maybe it is just me, but seems the non winners sometime fair better here.... Chris Daughty, Jennifer Houston (I think is her name) I have yet to like an actual winner. The 2 I dislike the most are Clay and Carrie.

iberlingirl wrote:

Cincy Fan 44 wrote:Gotta say I'm somewhat surprised Kris won. I still think Adam is better though. Time will tell which one has a better career...

Maybe it is just me, but seems the non winners sometime fair better here.... Chris Daughty, Jennifer Houston (I think is her name) I have yet to like an actual winner. The 2 I dislike the most are Clay and Carrie.

Just to clarify...Clay lost to Reuben.

And I have to fundementally disagree with you on Carrie. She's the BEST one that has won. I could be stranded on a deserted island with her the rest of my life and wouldn't care one bit. She on the other hand...

But I agree for the most part. Those that don't win seem to have better careers than the winners. Taylor Hicks, where are you? Fantasia? The aforementioned Reuben...anything?

Cincy Fan 44 wrote:I could be stranded on a deserted island with her the rest of my life and wouldn't care one bit.

That coca-cola song plays softly in the background of my mind.

Enjoy one on me!

God bless you Meta...that's one of the most thoughtful gifts anyone has ever given me...